Deeks VAT News – Issue 72: The latest to keep you (and your clients) compliant and clever

Deeks VAT News – Issue 72: The latest to keep you (and your clients) compliant and clever

Welcome to this issue of Deeks VAT News Keeping you up to date on VAT changes, case law and HMRC developments. VAT never really takes a day off. Just as one tribunal decision lands, HMRC updates a notice, a concession disappears, and someone somewhere discovers a brand-new way to make a simple tax point gloriously […]

Welcome to this issue of Deeks VAT News

Keeping you up to date on VAT changes, case law and HMRC developments.

VAT never really takes a day off. Just as one tribunal decision lands, HMRC updates a notice, a concession disappears, and someone somewhere discovers a brand-new way to make a simple tax point gloriously complicated.

This month, we look at ghost-written books, nursery meals, disability access cards, late appeals, and transfer pricing. In other words, the usual gentle mix of VAT, procedure, and mild administrative peril.

In this issue we cover:


Latest from the Courts

Story Terrace Limited: books or ghost-writing services? FTT

The First-tier Tribunal has found in favour of Story Terrace Limited in a dispute over whether its supplies should be treated as zero-rated books or standard-rated ghost-writing services.

Story Terrace creates biographies for customers using ghost writers. HMRC argued that the true supply was a writing service and should therefore be standard-rated. The Tribunal took a different view. After looking at the business model, customer contracts, website content and the way the service was presented, it concluded that the finished book was the element that mattered most to the customer.

The Tribunal found that, from the perspective of the typical consumer, the book itself was the predominant part of the supply. On that basis, the appeal was allowed.

This is a useful reminder that VAT liability often turns on what the customer is really buying, not simply on the steps involved behind the scenes.


Stellantis Portugal: VAT and transfer pricing – CJEU Advocate General opinion

This case considers an issue that will interest businesses operating in international groups: when does a transfer pricing adjustment have VAT consequences?

Stellantis Portugal purchased vehicles from manufacturers within its wider group and sold them on to independent dealers in Portugal. Under the transfer pricing arrangements, later adjustments were made to the vehicle pricing so that the Portuguese business met its target profitability. The Portuguese tax authority argued that the recharging of certain repair and distribution-related costs amounted to a taxable supply of services by Stellantis Portugal.

Advocate General Kokott disagreed.

In her view, transfer pricing is fundamentally a direct tax mechanism used to allocate profit between related entities. That does not automatically create a VATable supply. The VAT treatment depends on what the adjustment is actually doing. If it reflects a genuine separate service supplied for payment, VAT may arise. But where the adjustment simply alters the agreed price of goods already supplied, it is just that: a pricing adjustment, not a separate service.

That distinction matters. The opinion supports the view that not every intra-group adjustment should be treated as consideration for a taxable supply.


Slice of Pie Limited: supplies treated as catering, not zero-rated food

The First-tier Tribunal has dismissed the appeal of Slice of Pie Limited, holding that its supplies of hot meals to nurseries were standard-rated catering supplies rather than zero-rated food.

The company supplied freshly prepared meals to nurseries, with each food element delivered separately in containers so staff could portion and serve meals to children. Slice of Pie argued that this was simply the supply of food. HMRC said the overall arrangement had the character of catering.

The Tribunal agreed with HMRC. It placed weight on the fact that the meals were delivered hot, fully cooked, ready to eat, ordered in advance from a menu and intended for immediate consumption. Although nursery staff plated the meals, that was not enough to change the nature of the supply.

The Tribunal concluded that an ordinary person would see this as catering. It also found that the statutory tests pointed the same way: if the nursery was the relevant premises, the food was supplied for consumption there; if the supplier’s kitchen was the relevant premises, the meals were hot food supplied for consumption elsewhere. Either way, the result was standard-rating.

This decision is an important warning for nurseries and similar organisations that outsource meals, but cannot fully recover VAT.


Nimbus: ‘Access Cards’ for disabled users qualify for zero-rating

Nimbus: The Disability Consultancy Service Limited has succeeded before the First-tier Tribunal in a case concerning the VAT treatment of its Access Card.

The Access Card is used by disabled people to communicate their access needs and provide recognised evidence of those needs when dealing with venues and service providers. HMRC’s view was that the card was not eligible for zero-rating because it was merely a communication tool rather than qualifying equipment or an appliance designed solely for use by a disabled person.

The Tribunal found that the overall supply included disability verification, an electronic profile and the physical card itself, with the card being the predominant element from the customer’s perspective. It also found, however, that the arrangement was legally a supply of services rather than goods because ownership of the card remained with Nimbus.

That did not end the matter. The Tribunal accepted Nimbus’s alternative argument that the card was zero-rated because it was effectively let on hire to the disabled user. Under the relevant VAT rules, the letting on hire of qualifying equipment can fall within the zero-rate in the same way as an outright supply.

The result is a sensible and welcome decision, confirming that the legislation can still accommodate practical aids for disabled people even where the legal structure is not a straightforward sale.


The Khan Partnership LLP: costs awarded for unreasonable conduct in hardship proceedings

In The Khan Partnership LLP v HMRC, the First-tier Tribunal partly allowed HMRC’s application for costs arising from unreasonable conduct in relation to hardship proceedings.

The background is procedural but important. A taxpayer appealing a VAT assessment must usually either pay the disputed VAT first or make a successful hardship application. In this case, the original appeal incorrectly stated that the VAT had been paid. A hardship application followed much later, but the necessary supporting evidence was not provided promptly despite repeated requests.

The Tribunal decided that while it had limited scope to award costs in relation to the original appeal stage, it did have jurisdiction in relation to the hardship proceedings themselves. It found that the appellant’s behaviour during those proceedings had been unreasonable, particularly given the repeated delays and failure to comply with directions in good time.

HMRC was awarded costs of £3,151.80 for the period during which the hardship proceedings were ongoing.

The message is clear: hardship applications are a protective mechanism, but they still need to be handled properly and promptly.


Supreme Imports Ltd: late appeal application refused

In Supreme Imports Ltd, the Tribunal refused an application to bring an appeal out of time.

The decision follows the now familiar line of authority on late appeals and underlines the continuing importance of the Martland and Medpro approach. Businesses hoping to revive VAT disputes after deadlines have passed will need a strong explanation and supporting evidence. Delay alone is rarely fatal, but unexplained or poorly managed delay very often is.


Medpro: Court of Appeal restores the Martland approach

The Court of Appeal has now weighed in on the long-running Medpro dispute concerning late appeals.

The issue was whether the Upper Tribunal is entitled to give guidance to the First-tier Tribunal on how to exercise its discretion when deciding whether to allow an appeal out of time. The Court of Appeal held that it is.

That means the Martland guidance, as later developed in Katib, remains the correct framework. The First-tier Tribunal should continue to apply that guidance when dealing with applications for extensions of time.

This restores a more structured and consistent approach for procedural applications in VAT appeals. For advisers, it is another reminder that deadlines matter and that the Tribunal will expect a disciplined explanation where they have been missed.


Akin Kog: option to tax and deliberate inaccuracy

In Akin Kog, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal in a case involving the option to tax, undeclared output tax on rent and sale proceeds, and a personal liability notice.

The decision is notable because the Tribunal found there was no direct knowledge of the option to tax, but there was what is often described as “blind-eye knowledge”. That was enough to support the conclusion that the inaccuracy was deliberate.

Cases of this type are a reminder that failing to ask obvious questions can be just as dangerous as knowing the answer and ignoring it.


HMRC Updates

Revenue and Customs Brief 1 (2026): Removal of linked goods concession

HMRC has published Revenue and Customs Brief 1 (2026) confirming the withdrawal of the extra-statutory concession described in paragraph 3.7 of Notice 48.

The concession applied to minor promotional items supplied as part of linked supplies schemes. HMRC now says the concession is no longer required.

Businesses running promotional or incentive arrangements should review the VAT treatment of linked goods carefully, especially where historic practice has relied on HMRC guidance rather than clear legislative wording. The first step in determining the VAT treatment of a transaction is to establish whether the supply is a single supply or a mixed supply.

Sometimes the removal of a concession changes very little in practice. Sometimes it changes a great deal. This is one worth checking, not assuming.


Sonder case update

Many in the travel sector will remember the uncertainty created when Sonder US entered bankruptcy, throwing doubt over whether its significant TOMS appeal would continue.

Since then, a considerable amount of work has taken place behind the scenes. Advisers, stakeholders and insolvency representatives have all been looking at ways to keep the appeal alive. Funding has, unsurprisingly, been one of the major issues. While there is clear appetite within the sector for a crowdfunding solution, that route brings with it a range of legal, regulatory and anti-money laundering considerations.

The latest development is that the Court of Appeal has granted a stay in the Sonder matter. In practical terms, that means the hearing has not been cancelled but postponed. One reason for that stay is that the Bolt TOMS case, expected to be heard earlier, may establish relevant precedent. Just as importantly, the pause creates additional time to secure the funding needed for the Sonder appeal to proceed.

For businesses affected by TOMS, this means the case is still alive. It has not disappeared, and it has not been abandoned. There is still uncertainty, but this is a positive step for those hoping the issues will be properly argued before the Court of Appeal.

We will keep monitoring developments and provide updates as matters progress.


If any of the issues in this month’s newsletter affect you or your clients, please get in touch. Whether it is a dispute with HMRC, a tricky VAT liability point, or a business model that has wandered into a tax grey area, we are always happy to help bring clarity.

Jane Deeks
Deeks VAT Consultancy

jane@deeksvat.co.uk | 07710 553831 | LinkedIn

Share this page